Our Menu
All menu items are available for takeout.
Appetizers
Wagon Rolls
2 pcs $6.95 | 4 pcs $12.95 • Handmade eggrolls stuffed with our slow-smoked brisket & premium Wisconsin cheddar served with our homemade Carolina gold BBQ sauce.
Cheese Curds
$9.95
½ Pound of premium Wisconsin cheese curds served with our Alabama white BBQ sauce.
Bella Flats
$9.95
½ Pound of deep-fried Portabella mushroom slices with our homemade Alabama white BBQ sauce.
Buffalo Chicken Tenders
$9.95
½ Pound of breaded chicken tenders tossed in homemade buffalo sauce. Served with carrots, celery, and ranch dressing.
Onion Rings
$6.95
½ Pound of breaded gourmet thick-cut onion rings.
Soup & Salads
Southwest Salad
$13.95
Choice of pork or chicken on a bed of romaine lettuce with diced tomatoes, onions, black beans, corn, and six cheddar cheese. Served with southwest ranch dressing substitute • Carved Brisket +$3.00 or Burnt Ends +$4.00
Caesar Salad
$7.95
Add Pulled Chicken or Pork +$4.00 | Brisket +6$6.00 | Burnt Ends +$7.00
Dinner Salad
$5.95
Ranch, thousand islands, French, Italian, blue cheese, balsamic vinaigrette, southwest ranch.
Smoked Prime Rib Chili
$9.95
Tender chunks of smoked prime rib. kidney and black beans. Served with cornbread.
Chicken Tortilla Soup
$8.95
Clam Chowder
$5.95
Friday's
Comfort Food
Mac n' Cheese
$6.95
Made with Monterrey Jack and Wisconsin cheddar.
Mac n' Chili
$9.95
Mac n' Chicken or Pork
$10.95
Mac n' Brisket
$12.95
Mac n' Burnt Ends
$13.95
Platters
Served with cornbread, pickles, and two sides • Substitute a side for a small dinner salad +$2.00
St. Louis Ribs
$22.95
1/2 rack of hickory & cherry wood smoked • Make it a full rack +10.00
Brisket Burnt Ends
$24.95
A 10-ounce serving of cubed USDA Prime Texas beef brisket. Double-smoked with caramelized BBQ sauce.
Carved Brisket
$22.95
A 10-ounce serving of 14-hour slow-smoked USDA Prime Texas beef brisket hand-carved to order.
Smoked 1/2 Chicken
$15.95
Hickory & cherry wood smoked chicken.
Pulled Chicken
$15.95
A 10-ounce serving of pulled smoked chicken.
Pulled Pork
$15.95
A 10-ounce serving of cherry & hickory wood-smoked premium pork.
Friday Fish Fry
$15.95
Two pieces of premium cod, hand-dipped in a Guinness beer batter, served with our signature slaw, seasoned potato wedges & roll • Add Extra Piece of Cod +$3.50
Sandwiches
Substitute wedges for Mac, Beans, Slaw, Elotes +$1.00 | Potato Pancakes +$2.00 | Small Dinner Salad +$2.00
Brisket Burnt Ends
$17.95
Our savory burnt ends on a toasted brioche bun.
Carved Brisket
$16.95
Beef brisket carved to order on a toasted brioche bun.
Pulled Pork
$11.95
Cherry & hickory smoked pork.
Pulled Chicken
$11.95
Cherry & hickory smoked chicken.
Smokehouse Burger
$13.95
Cherry & hickory smoked ½ pound Black Angus patty on a toasted brioche bun. Topped with a thick-cut onion ring and pickles. Gouda cheese & Alabama white BBQ sauce.
Lil' Sheriff's Menu
All kids' menu items come with potato wedges, applesauce, fruit snacks & a drink | 12 and under
Mac n' Cheese
$5.00
Chicken Tenders
$5.00/2 pcs
Smoked Chicken Legs
$5.00/3 pcs
St. Louis Ribs
$5.00/2 pcs
Family Platter
Appetizer: Onions Rings, Cheese Curds, Wagon Rolls (4), Bella Flats • Sides: Coleslaw, Macn' Cheese, Cowboy Beans. Blotes, Potato Pancakes
Small Family Platter
$84.95/4 - 5 peole
Half slab of St. Louis Style Ribs | Half a pound of USDA Prime Brisket | Half a pound of Premium Pulled Pork | Half a pound of Pulled Chicken • Add half a pound of Burnt Ends +$13.00 • Seasoned Potato Wedges | Four pieces of cornbread • Choice of 1 Appetizer |Choice of 2 Large Sides
Large Family Platter
$159.95/8 - 10 people
A full slab of St. Louis Style Ribs | Full pound of USDA Prime Brisket | Full pound of Premium Pulled Pork | Full pound of Pulled Chicken • Add a full pound of Burnt Ends +$25.00 • Seasoned Potato Wedges | Eight pieces of Corn Bread • Choice of 2 Appetizers | Choice of 4 Large Sides
Smoked Prime Rib Dinner
Last Saturday of each month, beginning at 4 pm
Smoked Prime Rib
Petite Cut (8 - 10oz) $24.95 | Traditional Cut (14 - 16oz) $34.95 • Served with your choice of two sides, dinner salad, and a roll.
Sides
Potato Pancakes
$5.50
Served with sour cream & applesauce.
House Made Coleslaw
$4.50
Elotes (Street Corn)
$4.50
Cowboy Beans
$4.50
A smoked four-bean and brisket Southern favorite.
Seasoned Potato Wedges
$4.50
Mac N' Cheese
Desserts
Personal Pan Pies
$4.95
Baked right here in Monticello | Apple, Cherry, Strawberry Rhubarb • Add a Scoop of Premium Vanilla Ice Cream +$2.50
Old Fashioned Carrot Cake
$6.95
Chocolate Lava Cake
$5.95
Chocolate Cake
$5.95
Ice Cream Sundae
$4.95
Premium vanilla ice cream with your choice of chocolate or caramel syrup topped with whipped cream.